The 2023 Cabernet Sauvignon Fay Vineyard is showing notably better from bottle than it did from barrel. A lovely example of a delicate, finesse-driven Cabernet, it features hints of violets, thyme and sage entwined with ripe black cherries. It's medium- to full-bodied and silky-textured on the palate, with a lingering finish framed by fine-grained tannins.
Wholly owned by Tuscany's Antinori family, this historic property's winemaking remains in the capable hands of Head Winemaker Marcus Notaro. Before coming to Stag's Leap Wine Cellars in 2013, Notaro worked with the Ste. Michelle-Antinori partnership in Washington State, so he seems to have a good working relationship with the Antinori family and the CEO there, Renzo Cotarella. "It's important to maintain classic Stag's Leap elegance," said Notaro.
We took the opportunity to taste the 2023s from bottle and 2024s from prepared barrel samples. "I think both 2023 and 2024 are very good but very different," said Notaro. "In 2024, the heat in July brought everything forward. So, we picked earlier, but that was because the grapes tasted good." The final numbers reveal that the alcohol levels in the 2024 wines are actually lower than the later-harvested 2023s.
"It's easy to make a super-ripe wine," said Notaro. "I think it's more challenging to make wines with more finesse and nuance. The best wines are when you match your style with what the area gives you."
At the winery's home property, with 112 planted acres certified as Regenerative Organic in 2024, Notaro described the differences between Fay ("more perfumed, elegant") and S.L.V. ("power, tannin") and what he hopes to achieve in Cask 23 ("persistence, grace"). Certainly, in these vintages, those characteristics shine through. For consumers whose budgets are more like mine, the Cabernet Sauvignon Artemis is a reliable bottling that seems to be reaching more consistent levels of quality at a reasonable price.
Published: May 07, 2026